Florida Roof Replacement: Types Of Roofing You Should Consider

Cover image for Florida Roof Replacement: Types Of Roofing You Should Consider
Alex Sparks
Alex Sparks
Updated - December 27, 2023

Florida's sunshine is rejuvenating, but your roof faces a different reality: relentless sun, torrential downpours, and salty air. Choosing the right material isn't just about aesthetics; it's a strategic balance of style, budget, and tough weather.

Familiar and affordable asphalt shingles offer a quick tune-up, while elegant clay and slate tiles weather any storm but come with a hefty price tag. Metal roofs boast modern flair and hurricane defiance, but installation can be tricky. Composite shingles straddle affordability and durability, while cool, flat TPO roofs keep energy bills humming low. Remember, no one-size-fits-all exists. Find a roofing maestro to harmonize your needs with Florida's unique chorus. Let your roof stand tall and proud, singing the sweet song of security and peace of mind.

Asphalt Shingles

"Close-up of black shingled roof made of asphalt material, providing durable and weather-resistant roofing solution."
Asphalt Material

While they dominate with cost-effectiveness, the long-term factors might be too overwhelming. At $4.00-$6.50 per square foot, translating to roughly $12,000 per roof, they reign as affordability champions. Easy installation and diverse color options, from vibrant greens to earthy browns, add to their initial charm.

However, Florida's relentless sun and hurricanes are major factors that one must consider. The average 20-25-year lifespan pales in comparison to hardier options, potentially requiring an expensive repeat performance sooner than desired. Sun-bleaching also steals their vibrancy, and wind vulnerability can lead to costly repairs. Consider asphalt a budget-friendly option, but always consult with a skilled roofing contractor first for better weather-resistant options for your Florida home.


  • Most affordable
  • Lightweight
  • Assessable
  • Color Variations


  • Short Lifespan (15-20 years)
  • Hurricane Vulnerability
  • Higher Cooling Cost
  • Environmental Concerns

Metal Roofing

"A monochrome image of a metallic wall, showcasing the use of metal material for roofing."
Metal Material

Choose from metal sheets or elegant standing seam panels, both available in vibrant colors or even ready for your personal paintbrush touch. This is a roof that won't be swayed by 140 mph winds or bleached by the sun's glare. While asphalt is a budget-friendly option, metal composes a safer weather-resistant option for your Florida home.


  • Extremely durable (40-70 years)
  • Durability
  • Low Maintenance
  • Recyclable


  • Costly Upfront
  • Soundproofing
  • Expert Installation
  • Specialized Repairs

Tile Roofing

"Close-up of a red tile roof made of durable and aesthetically pleasing tile material for roofing."
Tile Material

Tile is a great alternative option compared to metal roofs but offers much much more. Forged in the sun for 5,000 years, tile roofs stand ready to shield your Florida home from heat and storms. At $10-$18 per square foot, they may have a slightly higher price tag than asphalt and metal, but the material can last 50+ years.

While your neighbors contend with the constant tune of repair bills, enjoy years of peace of mind knowing your roof won't require replacement anytime soon. Clay shrugs off 150 mph winds like a seasoned dancer, leaving asphalt tattered in its wake. Fire? No sweat. Clay tiles laugh in the face of flames, offering peace of mind that money can't buy. From Spanish to Scania, these roofs come in styles that echo the beauty of Florida's diverse landscapes. Choose clay for a symphony of strength, beauty, and weather-defying performance that resonates for generations.


  • Extremely durable (50+ years)
  • Fire Resistant
  • Appealing Colors
  • Regulates House Temperature


  • Premium Cost
  • Additional Structural Support
  • Vulnerable to Impact
  • Specialized Labor

Slate Roofing

"Close-up of stone slate roof showcasing durable roofing material."
Stone Slate Material

Slate is very similar in price and durability to tile but offers a more modern look. Boasting a lifespan of 50-70 years for $9-$20 per square foot. Natural slate, quarried from the earth, whispers tales of ancient resilience. But if budget is your primary focus, synthetic options like fiber cement and bituminous slate are available.

Less costly yet fireproof, wind-defying, and hail-resistant, they offer peace of mind without breaking the bank. Choose slate for a weather-defying material that lasts for generations.


  • Unmatched lifespan (50-70 years)
  • Fire Resistant
  • Eco-friendly
  • Durable


  • Very expensive
  • Delicate to impact
  • Extremely heavy
  • Additional Structural Support

Composite Shingles

"Composite material black slate roof close-up."
Composite Material

Florida's sun and storms demand a tough, beautiful roof. Asphalt offers affordability, but fades fast and struggles in hurricanes. While metal boasts resilience, its cost can not be an option for everyone. Composite slate offers a nice balance of budget and beauty at a cost of around $3-$6 per square foot.

Made from recycled materials, these shingles mimic natural slate's timeless elegance, fooling even the seasoned roofing eye. They withstand Florida's sun without bleaching and shrug off wind and rain with ease. And at 2-3 times the lifespan of asphalt, they leave you humming with peace of mind, not repair bills.


  • Durable (30-50 years)
  • Affordability with aesthetics
  • Eco-friendly (rubber and plastic)


  • Limited weather-resistant
  • Some styles require ventilation
  • Newer material (Roofing Industry)

Flat Roof

"A man holds torch, while putting down TPO material."
Flat roof

Ditch the pointy mountains, imagine a roof as flat as your floor! Flat roofs, perfect for Florida's sunshine, offer bonus space for rooftop gardens, starry terraces, or sun-loving solar panels. But remember, these low-riders need extra care. They last about 15-20 years, costing roughly $4-$13 per square foot. Think sunny mornings in your rooftop garden, but also regular checkups to keep this flat friend happy. Talk to a roofing pro to see if this space-saving, sun-loving option fits your Florida home!


  • Space optimization
  • Energy efficiency
  • Lower initial cost
  • Easy maintenance


  • Drainage issues
  • Limited ventilation
  • Susceptible to wind damage
  • Short Lifespan (15-20 years)


Navigating all of the types of roofing materials options in Florida can be daunting. From budget-friendly asphalt to timeless clay tiles, each material has its pros and cons. But in this sunshine state, where relentless sun and unpredictable storms hold the reins, finding the perfect balance of style, resilience, and affordability is vital.

This blog explored the unique melody of various roofing materials, helping you understand their strengths and weaknesses. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all masterpiece. Your ideal roof will depend on your individual needs, budget, and aesthetic preferences.

Always consult with a skilled roofing contractor first to ensure your home will be protected and look great for years to come. Whether you prefer the affordability of composite shingles or the enduring legacy of clay tiles, let your roof stand tall and proud.

Article Sources

Focus on specific roofing materials:

Additional resources: